The association between the clinical manifestations of benign breast d
isease (BBD) and mammographic patterns was investigated among 1394 wom
en (923 pre-menopausal and 471 postmenopausal) participating to the Ca
nadian National Breast Screening Study in Vancouver, who completed a q
uestionnaire designed to collect detailed information on the symptoms
and signs of BED, hormonal, reproductive and dietary factors. Mastalgi
a was present in 637 (46%) women and was cyclical in 505 (79%). Breast
swelling was noted in 331 women (23%) and mammary dysplasia involving
50% or more of the breast parenchyma in 733 (43%). Mastalgia was high
ly associated with breast swelling (odds ratios [OR] = 29.9, 95% confi
dence interval [CI] = 21.3-41.8), particularly when cyclical and chara
cterized by tenderness with pain (OR = 58.4, 95% CI = 39.1-87.0). The
relative risk for mammary dysplasia involving 50% or over of the breas
t parenchyma was significant in premenopausal women having breast swel
ling(OR = 2.96, 95% CI = 1.81-4.83), being highest in women with cycli
cal mastalgia associated with tenderness and pain (OR = 3.43, 95% CI =
1.49-7.92); similar associations were noted in post-menopausal women.
This study indicates that mastalgia is strongly related to breast swe
lling, especially when tenderness is associated with pain. Furthermore
, mastalgia associated with breast swelling is highly related to the p
resence of mammary dysplasia involving 50% or more of the breast paren
chyma in both pre- and post-menopausal women, suggesting that cyclical
tenderness and breast swelling may carry an increased breast cancer r
isk.