Mc. Miedema et al., RECOMMENDED MAXIMUM HOLDING TIMES FOR PREVENTION OF DISCOMFORT OF STATIC STANDING POSTURES, International journal of industrial ergonomics, 19(1), 1997, pp. 9-18
The aim of the present study was threefold; (1) to analyze the influen
ce of posture on the maximum holding time (MHT), (2) to study the poss
ibility of classifying postures on the basis of MHT, and (3) to develo
p ergonomic recommendations for the MHT of categories of postures. For
these purposes data concerning the MHT of 19 symmetric standing postu
res from 7 experimental studies from the literature were analyzed. All
postures were defined by the position of the hands with respect to th
e feet. For each posture the mean MHT over all available data was calc
ulated. The results show that for the 19 postures this mean MHT ranges
from 2 to 35 minutes. For a given posture the variation in MHT betwee
n different studies is large. It seems that in particular the type of
task (boring versus interesting) performed while maintaining the postu
re has a great influence on the MHT. On the basis of the mean MHT post
ures were classified into three classes. Comfortable postures are defi
ned as postures that have a MHT of more than 10 minutes and are recomm
ended not to be maintained more than 2 minutes. Moderate postures have
a MHT of 5-10 minutes and are recommended to be maintained for less t
han 1 minute. Uncomfortable postures, having a MHT up to 5 minutes, ar
e not acceptable. It is estimated that with theses recommendations a d
iscomfort of more than 2 (weak discomfort) on the Borg 10-point rating
scale (up to maximum discomfort) is prevented for at least 50% of the
population, and a discomfort of more than 5 (strong discomfort) is pr
evented for at least 95% of the population. The recommended holding ti
me valid for each class corresponds with the lowest recommended holdin
g time of that class. Therefore the recommendations are safe for all p
ostures. Our classification of postures corresponds well with classifi
cations based on biomechanical and anthropometric data and is more str
ict than the OWAS-classification. Relevance to industry Many work situ
ations in industry require static standing postures. Maintaining a pos
ture for a longer period of time may lead to feelings of discomfort. T
his study presents recommendations for maximum holding time based on e
xperimental data.