Pr. Leeshaley et al., RESPONSE BIAS IN SELF-REPORTED HISTORY OF PLAINTIFFS COMPARED WITH NONLITIGATING PATIENTS, Psychological reports, 79(3), 1996, pp. 811-818
Response bias refers to systematic error in the data produced by patie
nts or research subjects, e.g., due to erroneous recall or reporting.
In forensic set tings, response bias appears to be associated with the
nature of the proceedings. The present study rested whether patients
in litigation exhibit different response patterns than nonlitigating p
atients when asked about their preinjury problems. 34 litigants and 80
nonlitigants rated various areas of cognitive and emotional functioni
ng as problematic in the past and currently. The primary finding was t
hat plaintiffs reported preinjury functioning superior to that of cont
rols. These findings suggest the need for caution in inferences that l
itigants are either reliable or deceitful because response biases may
affect self-reports in a misleading fashion.