Mp. Mchugh et al., PULSAR TIMING AND THE UPPER LIMITS ON A GRAVITATIONAL-WAVE BACKGROUND- A BAYESIAN-APPROACH, Physical review. D. Particles and fields, 54(10), 1996, pp. 5993-6000
Stringent limits on Omega, the energy density in a gravitational wave
background per logarithmic frequency interval in units of the closure
density, have recently been suggested by Thorsett and Dewey using obse
rvational data of PSR B1855+09. We show that their use of the Neyman-P
earson test of hypotheses cannot, in the general case, provide reliabl
e upper limits on an unknown parameter. The alternative presented here
is the calculation of the probability distribution and repartition fu
nction for Omega using a Bayesian formalism. A prior distribution must
be specified and the choice of ''Jeffreys' prior'' is justified on th
e grounds that it best represents a total lack of prior knowledge abou
t the parameter. The Bayesian approach yields an upper limit at 95% co
nfidence of 9.3 x 10(-8) for Omega h2(.) This limit is less stringent
by a factor of 10 than that placed by Thorsett and Dewey.