H. Tobe et Nr. Morin, EMBRYOLOGY AND CIRCUMSCRIPTION OF CAMPANULACEAE AND CAMPANULALES - A REVIEW OF LITERATURE, Journal of plant research, 109(1096), 1996, pp. 425-435
Embryological studies of Campanulaceae and related families were revie
wed to add to discussion of appropriate circumscription of Campanulace
ae and Campanulales. Embryological features very uniform Campanulaceae
sens. lat. (Campanuloideae and Lobelioideae), and provide no evidence
for the separation of Lobelioideae as a distinct family. Campanulacea
e sens. lat. share with several other families traditionally included
in Campanulales (or Asterales) a few derived embryological features (i
.e., unitegmic and tenuinucellate ovules, an endothelium, ab initio Ce
llular type endosperm, and an endosperm haustorium). However, an exten
sive comparison with families in an expanded Asteridae shows that thos
e derived embryological features are symplesiomorphies, rather than sy
napomorphies indicative of close relationships among them. Combined wi
th other morphological (inferior ovary), chemical (presence of inulin)
, and molecular (rbcL gene nucleotide sequence) characters, embryologi
cal features rather support a broad circumscription of Campanulales (o
r Asterales) including Pentaphragmataceae, Stylidiaceae, Campanulaceae
sens. let., Donatiaceae, Menyanthaceae, Calyceraceae, Goodeniaceae, a
nd Asteraceae. Within Campanulales sens. fat. (or Asterales sens. lat.
), Menyanthaceae, Calyceraceae, Goodeniaceae, and Asteraceae are obvio
usly closely related to one another. To understand more exact relation
ships within the order, embryological studies are needed on Brunonia,
Cyphia, Cyphocarpus, Nemacladus, Corokia, Abrophyllum, Argophyllaceae,
and Alseousmiaceae.