The questions regarding the most effective technique of modeling stiff
ened shells persist despite the extensive literature available, In thi
s study, ring-stiffened cylinders having widely varying radius-to-thic
kness ratios are analyzed by using alternative approaches for determin
ation of their buckling strength under pressure, The approaches consid
ered here are 1) linear stability analysis using a two-dimensional mod
el, 2) linear stability analysis using a three-dimensional model, 3) n
onlinear bifurcation analysis using a two-dimensional model, and 4) no
nlinear bifurcation analysis using a three-dimensional model, In-house
computer programs based on p-version ring elements have been develope
d for these approaches. A homogenization technique has been utilized f
or treating composite laminates made of a large number of repetitions
of a basic sequence of plies. The results are compared with those give
n by currently available computer codes such as BOSOR, ABAQUS, and oth
ers, For thin shells, linear stability analysis can significantly over
estimate the buckling capacity, For moderately thick shells, the linea
r and nonlinear approaches give close results for overall buckling but
can differ significantly for local buckling. This is largely due to e
nd effects where the buckling mode is localized, For two-dimensional m
odels, the precise manner of connecting the shell and stiffener seems
to be important, As may be expected, as the thickness of the shell or
the stiffener increases, the two-dimensional models are found to be le
ss and less accurate.