We study the frequency dependence of the irreversibility temperature T
i,, in single crystal, thin film and ceramic Y-Ba-Cu-O samples. T-irr,
measured by the onset of third harmonic signal, depends weakly on fre
quency for crystals, moderately for thin films and strongly for cerami
c samples. The data is analyzed in the framework of the flux creep and
the vortex-glass models. Although we cannot rule out the flux creep s
cenario, the data is better described by the vortex-glass phase transi
tion model.