D. Gallo et al., EVALUATION OF A SYSTEM USING ORAL MUCOSAL TRANSUDATE FOR HIV-1 ANTIBODY SCREENING AND CONFIRMATORY TESTING, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 277(3), 1997, pp. 254-258
Objective.-To determine accuracy of a human immunodeficiency virus typ
e 1 (HIV-1) antibody testing system using a device to collect and stab
ilize oral mucosal transudate (OMT), a fluid with increased levels of
IgG; an enzyme immunoassay (EIA) screening test optimized for OMT; and
a Western blot confirmatory test designed for use with OMT, Design.-T
he OMT specimens were tested by EIA and, if indicated, confirmatory We
stern blot according to a standard testing algorithm. The OMT results
were compared with true HIV status as determined by serum testing and/
or clinical diagnosis. Patients.-Specimens from 3570 subjects (2382 at
low risk, 698 at high risk, 242 with acquired immunodeficiency syndro
me [AIDS], and 248 ''nonspecificity'' [persons with diseases associate
d with an increased frequency of false-positive results in HIV testing
]) were collected at If geographically diverse sites (including blood
banks, public health clinics, general medical clinics, HIV clinics, se
xually transmitted disease clinics, and a hemophilia center) in the Un
ited States. Main Outcome Measures.-Overall accuracy of testing OMT fo
r HIV-1 antibodies compared with true HIV-1 antibody status; sensitivi
ty and specificity of OMT EIA and Western blot, Results-Sensitivity of
OMT EIA testing in 673 true-positive subjects was 99.9% (672/673). Th
e OMT Western blot results in the 673 true-positive subjects were posi
tive in 665 and indeterminate in 8. The EIA followed by Western blot (
a EIA was repeatedly reactive) yielded a negative result in 99.9% (289
3/2897) of OMT samples from true negatives and an indeterminate result
in 4. The OMT testing system provided the correct result or would tri
gger appropriate follow-up testing in 3569 (>99.9%) of 3570 cases, Con
clusion.-HIV-1 antibody testing of OMT samples is a highly accurate al
ternative to serum testing.