This article reevaluates the effects of high school vocational educati
on on students' odds of being unemployed and students' occupational at
tainment in the transition from school to work. The question posed is
whether vocational secondary education actually benefits its clientele
or is simply the crude mechanism of social exclusion that some claim
it to be. The authors find that although vocational education inhibits
students' likelihood of attending college and subsequently of finding
employment in the professions and managerial occupations, it also red
uces the risk of unemployment and increases students' chances of emplo
yment as skilled workers. Therefore, for students who are unlikely to
continue on to college, vocational education is a safety net that redu
ces the risk of falling to the bottom of the labor queue.