Ro. Miller et al., A PROFICIENCY TESTING PROGRAM FOR THE AGRICULTURE LABORATORY INDUSTRYRESULTS OF THE 1994 PROGRAM, Communications in soil science and plant analysis, 27(3-4), 1996, pp. 451-461
The accuracy of soil and plant analytical results are occasionally cal
led into question by laboratory clientele. Although laboratories gener
ally conduct internal quality assurance procedures, there are few exte
rnal performance testing programs for the industry, In the spring of 1
994, a proficiency testing program was initiated for soil and plant sa
mples for agricultural laboratories in the Western United States to pr
ovide an external quality control for the laboratory industry. The pro
gram involves the quarterly exchange of soil and plant samples on whic
h soil salinity, soil fertility, and plant nutrition analyses are cond
ucted. For the 1994 program, 103 laboratories from 23 states and Canad
ian provinces participated. Overall, soil salinity and pH analyses wer
e highly reproducible across soils and laboratories through the year.
Variability in soil nitrate results were lower than noted in past inte
rlaboratory exchanges independent of soil sample. Results for extracta
ble soil bicarbonate phosphorus were variable independent of soil and
indicate a significantly positive skewed distribution. Plant nitrogen
(N) and phosphorus (P) results were consistent across samples, laborat
ories, and methods. Variability in plant nitrate increased with:decrea
sing tissue concentrations. Overall accuracy and precision of reported
results, based on the use of a NIST certified reference botancial sam
ple, were excellent for N, P, potassium (K), calcium (Ca), and copper
(Cu). Generally for any given analysis the results of approximately 10
% of the laboratories exceed two standard deviations from the mean. Ov
erall, significant improvement was noted in the laboratory industry pr
oficiency through the course of the year for the program.