C. Cicero et Nk. Johnson, SPECIATION IN SAPSUCKERS (SPHYRAPICUS) .3. MITOCHONDRIAL-DNA SEQUENCEDIVERGENCE AT THE CYTOCHROME-B LOCUS, The Auk, 112(3), 1995, pp. 547-563
We amplified and sequenced a 711 base-pair (bp) fragment of mtDNA at t
he cytochrome-b locus to reexamine relationships within and among spec
ies of Sphyrapicus and representatives of two other woodpecker genera
(Melanerpes, Colaptes). Sequences were obtained from 10 individuals of
5 taxa: Red-breasted Sapsucker (S. ruber daggetti), n = 2; Red-naped
Sapsucker (S. nuchalis), n = 2; hybrid of S. ruber daggetti x S. nucha
lis, n = 1; Yellow-bellied Sapsucker (S. varius varius), n = 2; Willia
mson's Sapsucker (S. thyroideus thyroideus), n = 2; and Red-bellied Wo
odpecker (M. carolinus), n = 1. The Melanerpes sequence and a comparab
le published sequence of Andean Flicker (C. rupicola) were used as out
groups. Levels of mtDNA sequence divergence ranged from 0.0 to 0.6% wi
thin species and 0.1 to 10.2% among species of Sphyrapicus, and from 1
2.5 to 14.5% between members of Sphyrapicus and the two outgroup speci
es. One region of sequence (78 bp) was identified as being especially
conserved. Branching topologies based on this study corroborated resul
ts from a previous analysis of relationships in Sphyrapicus using allo
zymes: the phenotypically dissimilar species ruber and nuchalis are mo
st closely related; varius, which is very similar in appearance to nuc
halis, branches off next; and thyroideus, the most divergent member of
the quartet from the standpoint of plumage pattern and degree of sexu
al dimorphism, is strongly differentiated genetically. Pairwise mtDNA
distances within Sphyrapicus showed a strong curvilinear relationship
with allozyme distances (r = 0.996). The monophyly of Sphyrapicus is r
eaffirmed, with S. thyroideus closer to the ancestral species. Members
of Sphyrapicus are more similar to Melanerpes than to Colaptes based
on their mtDNA. Prior hypotheses regarding the evolutionary history of
sapsuckers in North America are discussed. Despite the near genetic i
dentity of ruber and nuchalis based on both allozymes and mtDNA sequen
ces, and their tendency for limited hybridization in sympatry, an earl
ier study of mating preference supports the biologic-species status of
these taxa.