The effect of conventional ear plugs and ear muffs, and muffs with lim
ited dichotic amplification on the ability to localize one-third octav
e noise bands was investigated under semi-reverberant listening condit
ions. Forty-eight normal-hearing subjects, half over 40 years of age,
and 23 subjects with bilateral sensorineural hearing loss participated
. Sound localization was assessed using an array of six loudspeakers s
urrounding the subject at azimuth angles 60 degrees apart. One block o
f 120 forced-choice speaker identification trials was presented for ea
ch of 16 listening conditions defined by ear condition (unoccluded, E-
A-R plug, E-A-R muff, and Bilsom 2392 muff), stimulus frequency (500 H
z and 4000 Hz), and background (quiet and continuous 65 dB SPL-white n
oise). Plugs and muffs, particularly active muffs, resulted in decreme
nts in right/left judgments based on interaural intensity but not time
-of-arrival differences. High-frequency front/back discrimination was
affected more by muffs than by plugs. Error patterns for the conventio
nal and active muffs were dissimilar. Aging resulted in a decrement in
unoccluded front/back discrimination. Trends for the impaired subject
s were the same as those for normal subjects at 500 Hz. Many could not
hear 4000 Hz with conventional protectors. Their performance was no d
ifferent from normal with the active muffs.