F. Halimi et al., ROLE OF POWER AND THERMAL REGULATION IN R ADIOFREQUENCY ABLATION, Archives des maladies du coeur et des vaisseaux, 89(2), 1996, pp. 243-248
Variations of temperature, impedance and power and the relationship be
tween these three factors were studied in 20 patients during 351 appli
cations of radiofrequency energy delivered by a generator with a regul
ated output power. The applications were divided into 3 groups accordi
ng to the maximal temperature attained: group I (< 50 degrees C;n = 11
2), group II (50-60 degrees C;n = 100), and group III (60-70 degrees C
;n = 139).Analysis of the total duration of time of applications (aver
age +/- standard deviation) showed : the duration (seconds) was 23.9 /- 11.9 seconds for group I, 36.1 +/- 18.7 seconds for group II and 45
+/- 23.6 seconds for group III. The time to attain maximal temperatur
e was 6.8 +/- 9.6 seconds in group I, 11.7 +/- 12.7 in group II and 10
+/- 10.4 seconds in group III. The impedance remained under 200 Omega
in all applications, the target temperature being set at 70 degrees C
. Analysis of the first three seconds of application : correlations co
efficients between temperature and Impedance were -0.08 (p < 0.001) in
group I and -0.23 (p < 0.0001) in groups II and III. These coefficien
ts were recalculated with respect to the average power delivered durin
g the applications : < 40 watts (n = 79), r = -0.33; < 30 watts (n = 5
5), r = -0.41; < 20 watts (n = 33), r = 0.49 and < 10 watts (n = 15),
r = -0.7 (p < 0.0001). The authors conclude that radiofrequency genera
tors with thermal regulation allow early interruption of ineffective a
pplications of radiofrequency and avoid increases in impedance. The po
or correlations observed between increase in temperature (measured at
the tip of the catheter) and the fall in impedance (related to tissue
heating) for the first 3 groups, show that temperature alone is not a
good indicator of contact. The improvement of the correlations for dec
reasing output power applications indicates better thermal transfer be
tween the electrode and endocardium. Therefore a low power delivered i
n the first seconds at > 50 degrees C is to be interpreted as a marker
of the quality of contact and a predictive factor of efficacy.