Mj. Tipton et Pj. Balmi, THE EFFECT OF WATER LEAKAGE ON THE RESULTS OBTAINED FROM HUMAN AND THERMAL MANNEQUIN TESTS OF IMMERSION PROTECTIVE CLOTHING, European journal of applied physiology and occupational physiology, 72(5-6), 1996, pp. 394-400
The effect of both the volume and location of water leakage on the pro
tection provided by an uninsulated immersion suit was investigated usi
ng human subjects and, in corresponding experiments, an immersion ther
mal manikin. Three volumes of ''leakage'' to the torso (200, 500 and 1
000 ml) were examined, as were two conditions in which no leakage was
simulated and one condition in which a 500-ml leak to the limbs was si
mulated. All leakages were introduced in a standardised way before imm
ersion. The measurements of clothing insulation obtained, both rom the
manikin and the humans, were in general agreement. The hub man experi
mentation provided some support for a 200-ml limit to water leakage in
tests of immersion suits. Rectal and aural temperatures remained sign
ificantly (P < 0.05) higher when a 500-ml leak was applied to the limb
s rather than the torso; this was primarily due to greater heat flow t
hrough and from the torso (back) during the immersions with torso wett
ing. The physiological responses and anthropometric characteristics wh
ich determine this response are not present in manikins; the implicati
ons of this for the application and design of immersion thermal maniki
ns, as well as the protection of those at risk of immersion in cold wa
ter, are discussed. It is concluded that using immersion thermal manik
ins to provide a single overall measure of clothing insulation will no
t necessarily distinguish between suits which provide quite different
levels of protection for humans.