Governments occasionally suspend fundamental norms within a territoria
lly limited enclave in response to perceived necessity. Professor Neum
an refers to such enclaves as ''anomalous zones'' and explains the den
ial of constitutional rights to Haitian and Cuban refugees detained at
Guantanamo Bay Naval Base as an example of this phenomenon. He examin
es at length two other examples, the formalized toleration of prostitu
tion in legal red light districts, and the disenfranchisement of the D
istrict of Columbia. He infers from these examples that anomalous zone
s unleash a subversive potential that extends beyond their designated
boundaries and their original purposes. Viewing Guantanamo from this p
erspective provides further confirmation of the dangers of anomalous z
ones.