The existence of correlation between the carcinogenic potency and the
maximum tolerated dose has been the subject of many investigations in
recent years. Several attempts have been made to quantify this correla
tion in different bioassay experiments. By using some distributional a
ssumptions, Krewski et al.((1)) derive an analytic expression for the
coefficient of correlation between the carcinogenic potency TD,, and t
he maximum tolerated dose. Here, we discuss the deviation that may res
ult in using their analytical expression. By taking a more general app
roach we derive an expression for the correlation coefficient which in
cludes the result of Krewski et al.((1)) as a special case, and show t
hat their expression may overestimate the correlation in some instance
s and yet underestimate the correlation in other instances. The propos
ed method is illustrated by application to a real dataset.