The mechanism of the hydrolysis of acetonitrile to ammonium ion in the
presence of NbCl5 has been investigated. Two possible mechanisms are
discussed: metal-assisted (catalysed) hydrolysis and a mechanism based
on the addition of alcohol and HCl to the CN triple bond to give init
ially an imidate hydrochloride salt, which may undergo further hydroly
sis to the ester and ammonium ion (Pinner synthesis). Support for this
route came from the spectroscopic identification of the alkoxyimminiu
m ion intermediate, CH3C(OCH3) = NH2+. Although the reaction is not ca
talysed by Nb, the extent or reaction is strongly related to the amoun
t of Nb present. It is concluded that the Pinner reaction is operating
with the amount of HCl available for the reaction being controlled by
the Nb concentration.