The purpose of our study was to prospectively determine pneumonia freq
uency and correlate it with prandial liquid aspiration and feeding sta
tus in frail elderly nursing home residents. Initially, 152 patients h
ad video swallowing examinations (81 oropharyngeal dysphagia, 19 thora
cic dysphagia, 52 without dysphagia). Those diagnosed with oropharynge
al impairment were subsequently managed with swallowing therapy or art
ificial feeding modalities. Patients were followed for 3 years (unless
they expired earlier) and clinical courses were categorized according
to the degree of prandial aspiration and feeding (PAF) status. Subjec
ts with new lung infiltrates persisting for at least 5 days with appro
priate clinical findings were diagnosed as having pneumonia and were c
lassified according to the PAF status months in which these findings o
ccurred. Fifty-six pneumonias were diagnosed during 4,280 months with
the following frequencies: no aspiration months 0.6%; minor aspiration
months 0.9%; major aspiration/oral feeding months 1.3%; major aspirat
ion/artificial feeding months 4.4%, p < 0.001. Our results indicate th
at there is not a simple and obvious relation between prandial liquid
aspiration and pneumonia. Artificial feeding does not seem to be a sat
isfactory solution for preventing pneumonia in elderly prandial aspira
tors.