Rw. Nightingale et al., EXPERIMENTAL IMPACT INJURY TO THE CERVICAL-SPINE - RELATING MOTION OFTHE HEAD AND THE MECHANISM OF INJURY, Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume, 78A(3), 1996, pp. 412-421
The purpose of this study was to analyze, with use of an impact model,
the relationships among motion of the head, local deformations of the
cervical spine, and the mechanisms of injury; the model consisted of
the head and neck of a cadaver, Traditionally, the mechanisms of injur
y to the cervical spine have been associated with flexion and extensio
n motions of the head and neck, However, the classification of the mec
hanisms is not always in agreement with the patient's account of the i
njury or with lacerations and contusions of the scalp, which indicate
the site of the impact of the head, Eleven specimens were dropped in a
n inverted posture with the head and neck in an anatomically neutral p
osition, Forces, moments, and accelerations were recorded, and the imp
acts were imaged at 1000 frames per second, The velocity at the time o
f impact was on the order of 3.2 meters per second, The angle and the
padding of the impact surface varied, Observable motion of the head di
d not correspond to the mechanism of the injury to the cervical spine,
Injury occurred 2.2 to 18.8 milliseconds after impact and before noti
ceable motion of the head, However, the classification of the mechanis
m of the injuries was descriptive of the local deformations of the cer
vical spine at the time of the injury, Accordingly, it is a useful too
l in describing the local mechanism of injury Buckling of the cervical
spine, involving extension between the third and sixth cervical verte
brae and flexion between the seventh and eighth cervical vertebrae, wa
s observed, Other, more complex, buckling deformations were also seen,
suggesting that the deformations that occur during impact are so comp
lex that they can give rise to a number of different mechanisms of inj
ury: CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Classic concepts of flexion and extension of
the head as a mechanism of injury do not apply to a vertical impact of
the head, Motions of the head, which often are used to classify the i
njury, are not a reliable indicator of the mechanism of injury. The me
chanism of injury is descriptive of local deformations of the cervical
spine and forces at the instant of injury, Although it is a useful to
ol for describing local mechanisms of injury care should be taken not
to confuse the mechanism of injury at the level of the motion segment
with the mechanism as it applies to loads on (and resulting motions of
) tile head, The complex buckling of the cervical spine that results f
rom a vertical impact of the head may cause concomitant flexion and ex
tension in different regions of the cer,icd spine, Treatment should be
based on the local mechanism, with the understanding that this type o
f impact may involve multiple, sometimes non-contiguous, mechanisms of
injury.