R. Neugebauer et al., ASSOCIATION OF STRESSFUL LIFE EVENTS WITH CHROMOSOMALLY NORMAL SPONTANEOUS-ABORTION, American journal of epidemiology, 143(6), 1996, pp. 588-596
Spontaneous abortion is the most common adverse reproductive outcome.
Despite evidence that negative life events increase risk for a number
of medical disorders, their role in pregnancy disruption has not been
investigated. The present study tested an a priori hypothesis that rec
ent negative life events increase the odds of spontaneous abortion of
a chromosomally normal conceptus. Between 1984 and 1986, 192 women age
d 18-42 years who visited a medical center after spontaneous abortion
were interviewed about positive and negative events that had occurred
in the 4-5 months preceding the loss. Subsequently, women with chromos
omally normal (n = 111) and chromosomally abnormal (n = 81) losses wer
e identified on the basis of tissue culture after interview. The women
with chromosomally abnormal loss provided an estimate of the expected
frequency of life events against which to compare the event frequenci
es of women with chromosomally normal loss. Analyses were adjusted for
duration of the recall period, payment status, maternal age, educatio
n, and ethnicity. Seventy percent of the women with chromosomally norm
al losses reported having had one or more negative life events in the
months preceding loss, compared with 52% of the women with chromosomal
ly abnormal losses (adjusted odds ratio = 2.6, 95% confidence interval
(CI) 1.3-5.2). For private patients (n = 69), the adjusted odds ratio
was 4.2 (95% CI 1.3-13.4); for public patients (n = 123), it was 1.9
(95% CI 0.8-4.8). The associations held for postconception events alon
e and were absent for positive events. Results were unaltered by adjus
tment for smoking, caffeine intake, and alcohol consumption, With reca
ll bias precluded by the study design, the strength, timing, and speci
ficity of these associations suggest that recent negative life events
play a role in chromosomally normal spontaneous abortion. Efforts to r
eplicate these results and to elucidate underlying biologic mechanisms
are required.