Lk. Dotterud et Es. Falk, METAL ALLERGY IN NORTH NORWEGIAN SCHOOLCHILDREN AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH EAR PIERCING AND ATOPY, Contact dermatitis, 31(5), 1994, pp. 308-313
In 424 schoolchildren (223 boys and 201 girls) aged 7-12 years undergo
ing routine patch tests, 21.0% (89 children), 38.8% (78/201) of girls
and 4.9% (11/223) of boys, had had their ears pierced. 18.6% (79 child
ren, 55 girls and 24 boys) gave a history of cutaneous reactions to me
tallic jewellery, and in 17.2% (73 children, 49 girls and 24 boys), se
nsitivity to one or more metals was confirmed. Metal allergy was confi
rmed by patch testing in only 34.2% of the children with a history of
metal dermatitis, and 13.3% of those without a history of metal reacti
ons had, in fact, positive patch tests to 1 or more metals. The low se
nsitivity (37.0%) and low positive predictive value (34.2%), together
with high specificity (85.2%) and high negative predictive value (86.7
%), seem to justify dermatological examination of individuals with a p
ositive symptom-based diagnosis only. Nickel sensitivity was found in
14.9% (63 children, 44 girls and 19 boys). There is clearly a relation
ship between ear piercing and induction of nickel allergy in girls, as
nickel sensitivity in girls with pierced ears was 2 x (30.8%) that fo
und in those without (16.3%) pierced ears. In boys, nickel sensitivity
was much less frequent and few cases were related to ear piercing, At
opy appeared to influence the propensity for developing metal sensitiv
ity in girls, as atopic girls showed positive metal tests 2 x as frequ
ently (30.8%) as non-atopic (17.0%). No such differences were found in
boys. Girls with a combination of atopy and ear piercing showed the h
ighest frequency of positive metal tests (45.5%). The frequency of met
al allergy increased with increasing number of holes in the ear lobes.
Symptoms of nickel allergy were reported in 30.2% (19/63) of mothers
whose children had nickel allergy, compared to 16.3% (59/361) of mothe
rs whose children had negative nickel tests. Only 4 children reported
symptoms of nickel allergy in their father. The high frequency of nick
el sensitivity in all children tested may indicate an influence of sou
rces other than ear piercing.