Measures of deviation of a symmetric positive definite matrix from the
identity are derived. They give rise to symmetric rank-one, SR1, type
updates; The measures are motivated by considering the volume of the
symmetric difference of the two ellipsoids, which arise from the curre
nt and updated quadratic models in quasi-Newton methods. The measure d
efined by the problem-maximize the determinant subject to a bound of 1
on the largest eigenvalue-yields the SR1 update. The measure sigma(A)
= lambda(1)(A)/det(A)(1)/(n) yields the optimally conditioned, sized,
symmetric rank-one updates. The volume considerations also suggest a
'correction' for the initial stepsize for these sized updates. It is t
hen shown that the sigma-optimal updates, as well as the Oren-Luenberg
er self-scaling updates, are all optimal updates for the kappa measure
, the l(2) condition number. Moreover, all four sized updates result i
n the same largest (and smallest) 'scaled' eigenvalue and correspondin
g eigenvector. In fact, the inverse-sized BFGS is the mean of the sigm
a-optimal updates, while the inverse of the sized DFP is the mean of t
he inverses of the sigma-optimal updates. The difference between these
four updates is determined by the middle n - 2 scaled eigenvalues. Th
e kappa measure also provides a natural Broyden class replacement for
the SR1 when it is not positive definite.