We consider a sequence of four-monthly predictions and estimates of qu
arterly U.S. real gross national product. The late forecasts are relea
sed in the final month of a quarter, and an initial estimate and two s
ubsequent revisions are published in the following three months. The q
uestion of efficiency is analyzed through considering the earlier figu
res as forecasts of this last number. The strongest indication of inef
ficiency appears in a nonlinear relationship between the third publish
ed number and each of the two previously reported estimates.