Female velvet swimming crabs (Necora puber) fight readily in the labor
atory, with interactions being initiated equally often by the larger a
nd smaller of the two opponents, but with the larger usually being vic
torious. In 17 out of 65 interactions, however, a smaller crab won aga
inst a larger one, and possible reasons for this are discussed. In two
respects our results are surprising in the context of insights gained
from games theory: firstly, the fights do not show a gradual pattern
of escalation through display to overt physical violence; and secondly
, fights do not become more costly in terms of either potential for in
jury (intensity) or duration as the contestants became more evenly mat
ched; indeed, as the contestants became more evenly matched, fight dur
ation decreased.