M. Satoh et al., ASSOCIATION OF AUTOANTIBODIES TO TOPOISOMERASE-I AND THE PHOSPHORYLATED (IIO) FORM OF RNA-POLYMERASE-II IN JAPANESE SCLERODERMA PATIENTS, The Journal of immunology, 153(12), 1994, pp. 5838-5848
Autoantibodies to RNA polymerases (RNAP) I and III are highly specific
for scleroderma (SSc), whereas autoantibodies to RNAP II are associat
ed with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and overlap syndromes, as w
ell as SSc. The specificities of autoantibodies to RNAP I, II, and III
in 129 SSc sera were investigated in the present study. Immunoprecipi
tation and pulse-chase analysis demonstrated several patterns of autoa
ntibody recognition of RNAPs. Some sera immunoprecipitated RNAP II onl
y after its largest subunit was phosphorylated, suggesting that they c
ontained autoantibodies that recognized an epitope carrying a phosphoa
mino acid. Autoantibody recognition of all three classes of RNAPs was
influenced strongly by race. Although in SLE, autoantibodies to the ph
osphorylated form of RNAP II (RNAP IIO) were identified in all races,
in SSc, these autoantibodies were seen in 21% of Japanese and 5% of Bl
ack patients, but never in Caucasians. A striking association of anti-
RNAP IIO with anti-topoisomerase I (topo I) autoantibodies was found i
n Japanese and Black SSc, but not SLE, patients. However, anti-topo I
Abs were not associated with anti-RNAP IIO in Caucasians. Japanese SSc
patients who were positive for both anti-RNAP IIO and anti-topo I Abs
had a significantly higher frequency of diffuse disease, pigmentation
changes, flexion contractures, and acro-osteolysis than patients havi
ng autoantibodies to topo I alone, and were diagnosed at a younger age
(p < 0.05). These data suggest that genetic factors (possibly HLA-lin
ked) influence autoantibody specificity, and that different autoantibo
dy fine specificities may either cause, or be predictive of, different
clinical outcomes.