G. Hajak et al., ZOPICLONE IMPROVES SLEEP QUALITY AND DAYTIME WELL-BEING IN INSOMNIAC PATIENTS - COMPARISON WITH TRIAZOLAM, FLUNITRAZEPAM AND PLACEBO, International clinical psychopharmacology, 9(4), 1994, pp. 251-261
In a randomized, double-blind, parallel group study in private practic
e, zopiclone given for 28 days was compared with flunitrazepam, triazo
lam and placebo in its effect on quality of sleep and daytime well-bei
ng in 1507 patients suffering from insomnia. For quantitative assessme
nt, patients were defined as responders according to either a shorteni
ng of sleep latency by at least 15 min, or prolongation of total sleep
time by at least 20%, or reduction of the number of nocturnal awakeni
ngs to three or less and a fresh feeling in the morning, as well as la
ck of impairment in daytime well-being as a result of tiredness or anx
iety. The responder rate tended to be higher with zopiclone (37.4%) th
an with flunitrazepam (30%) and triazolam (32.2%) and was significantl
y greater (p = 0.0017) than with placebo (26.8%). Daytime well-being w
as particularly responsive to zopiclone and most responsive in severe
insomniacs. With the exception of those to triazolam, rates of respons
e were most pronounced in patients with insomnia of a short duration (
less than or equal to 1 year) than in those with insomnia of a longer
duration (greater than or equal to 1 year). Following discontinuation
of treatment, all groups showed a moderate reduction in therapeutic ef
fect, but no rebound insomnia occurred.