Background. Carcinomatous meningitis is a rare and often devastating c
omplication in patients with breast cancer, and the treatment is contr
oversial. Methods. A retrospective analysis of 35 patients with carcin
omatous meningitis from breast cancer was performed to define the biol
ogy of the disease and to guide treatment. Results. An aggressive vari
ant of breast cancer was revealed: meningeal metastasis complicates le
ss than 3.5% of cases of metastatic breast carcinoma. Sixty-seven perc
ent of these patients had tumors that were lobular or combined lobular
/ductal histology; the median intervals from primary treatment to dise
ase recurrence and from recurrence to death were 10.9 and 15 months, r
espectively. The median survival after diagnosis of carcinomatous meni
ngitis was 77 days. The most significant prognostic factor was the Kar
nofsky performance status (KP) at presentation of meningeal disease. P
atients with a KP greater or equal to 70 survived a median of 313 days
, whereas those with a KP of 60 or less survived for a median of 36 da
ys (P = 0.0002), In addition, there was a trend suggesting that the re
sponse 2 weeks after treatment was initiated, correlated with survival
. Conclusions. Carcinomatous meningitis from breast carcinoma is an ag
gressive metastatic complication with a poor prognosis. The authors su
ggest that patients with a poor KP (< 70) should be treated symptomati
cally and those with a good KP (greater than or equal to 70) should re
ceive more aggressive treatment The patients' survival in this study c
ompared well with other reports, and yet, only one patient was treated
with intraventricular chemotherapy. Therefore, these data question th
e superiority of intraventricular treatment versus other modalities.