Ba. Boukamp et Jr. Macdonald, ALTERNATIVES TO KRONIG-KRAMERS TRANSFORMATION AND TESTING, AND ESTIMATION OF DISTRIBUTIONS, Solid state ionics, 74(1-2), 1994, pp. 85-101
Two alternatives to Kronig-Kramers analysis of small-signal ac immitta
nce data are discussed and illustrated using both synthetic and experi
mental data. The first, a derivative method of approximating imaginary
-part response from real-part data, is found to be too approximate in
regions where the imaginary-part varies appreciably with frequency. Th
e second, a distribution of relaxation-times fitting method, is shown
to be valuable for testing whether a data set satisfies the Kronig-Kra
mers relations and so is associated with a system whose properties are
time-invariant. It also is valuable for estimating real- or imaginary
-part response from the other part, usually with small error. Unlike K
ronig-Kramers analysis, the second method usually requires no extrapol
ation outside the range of the measured data. Finally, this discrete-f
unction method also allows one to estimate the distribution of relaxat
ion times or activation energies associated with a given set of freque
ncy-response data. This application is described and illustrated for b
oth synthetic and experimental data and is shown to yield good but som
ewhat approximate results for the estimation of continuous distributio
ns. It is particularly valuable for identifying response regions arisi
ng from a continuous distribution and distinguishing them from those a
ssociated with discrete time-constant response.