G. Swingler et al., AN AUDIT OF THE USE OF ANTIBIOTICS IN PRESUMED VIRAL MENINGITIS IN CHILDREN, The Pediatric infectious disease journal, 13(12), 1994, pp. 1107-1110
The antibiotic management of 139 consecutive patients with presumed vi
ral meningitis evaluated during a 6-month period was examined. The pre
sumptive diagnosis of viral meningitis was made in retrospect by conse
nsus among the authors, using clinical and routinely available laborat
ory information. Sixty-eight (51.9%) of 131 patients with complete rec
ords were treated with antibiotics after diagnosis, 25 for 2 days or l
ess and 43 for longer than 2 days. Antibiotic treatment was retrospect
ively judged to be unjustified in 35 (81.4%) of the 43 patients treate
d for longer than 2 days. When compared with untreated patients antibi
otic treatment was started in younger female children with lower cereb
rospinal fluid glucose values and longer duration of symptoms. There w
as no difference between the two groups in other cerebrospinal fluid v
alues, peripheral white blood cell count or history of preceding antib
iotics. In contrast no associations were found with treatment beyond 2
days, compared with treatment for 2 days or less. Thus the decision t
o stop antibiotic treatment early did not appear to be made according
to consistent clinical criteria. This apparent lack of consistent crit
eria suggests the need to develop clinical guidelines for such decisio
ns, both to aid clinicians and to provide standards for medical audit.