Cm. Koelmel et al., QUANTUM AND MOLECULAR MECHANICS STUDY OF THE TRIS(QUATERNARY AMMONIUM) CATION USED AS THE ZEOLITE ZSM-18 SYNTHESIS TEMPLATE, Journal of physical chemistry, 98(49), 1994, pp. 12911-12918
A combined first principles (both Hartree-Fock and local density funct
ional) and force field study of the preferred conformations and confor
mational flexibility of the tris(quaternary ammonium) examethyl-1H-ben
zo[1.2-c:3,4-c':6-c'']tripyrrolium 'triquat' cation [(C4H4N(CH3)(2)))(
3)](3+) is presented. The potential energy surface of this molecular c
ation is characterized by two local minima corresponding to C-3r and C
-s symmetry, respectively, and a triple transition state with respect
to pyrrolium ring inversion with D-3h symmetry. These structures were
each successfully located by both first principles and force field met
hodologies. Although the conformational energy differences obtained by
Hartree-Fock and local density functional methods agree well, some va
riability in the molecular mechanics results for different force field
s is found, underlining the need for a careful calibration of force fi
elds against experimental and/or ab initio data. The implications of t
he calculated energy barriers for ring inversion in the primary applic
ation of the triquat cation as a zeolite ZSM-18 templating agent are a
lso discussed.