R. Pernice et J. Brook, RELATIONSHIP OF MIGRANT STATUS (REFUGEE OR IMMIGRANT) TO MENTAL-HEALTH, International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 40(3), 1994, pp. 177-188
This study investigated and compared mental health levels among refuge
es and immigrants living in New Zealand. One hundred and twenty-nine I
ndochinese refugees, 57 Pacific Island immigrants and 63 British immig
rants to New Zealand were surveyed. A questionnaire and the Hopkins Sy
mptom Checklist-25 (HSCL-25) in English and in three Indochinese trans
lations, were administered face-to-face. The hypothesis that migrant s
tatus (being a refugee or immigrant) affects mental health and that re
fugees experience more emotional distress than immigrants was only sup
ported by the comparison with British immigrants. Both Indochinese ref
ugees and Pacific Island immigrants experienced relatively low levels
of mental health. However, the incidence of clinical depression and cl
inical total emotional distress tended to be higher among Indochinese
refugees than in either immigrant group. In contrast clinical anxiety
occurred most often among Pacific Islanders.