Ml. Turner et al., EFFECTS OF VOCABULARY SIZE AND ACOUSTIC SIMILARITY ON SERIAL-RECALL OF MOUTHED STIMULI, The Journal of general psychology, 121(4), 1994, pp. 361-376
The characteristics of mouthed recency and suffix effects found in imm
ediate serial recall tasks with visually presented stimuli were examin
ed. In past research enhanced recency with mouthing when stimuli were
drawn from Size 8 but not Size 3 vocabularies was found (Turner et al.
, 1987). One cause for these findings may have been differences in the
acoustic similarity between items from the Size 3 and Size 8 vocabula
ries. In the present experiment the degree of similarity was manipulat
ed for vocabulary Sizes 3 and 8. The mouthed or passively read letters
were acoustically similar, dissimilar, or mixed. The results replicat
ed the vocabulary size effects found in Turner et al. but were not con
founded by the acoustic similarity of the list items. Mouthed recency
and suffix effects were found in recall of Size 8 but not Size 3 vocab
ularies, and the vocabulary size effects were found regardless of acou
stic similarity. Conversely, research has found auditory recency and s
uffix effects to be dependent on the acoustic similarity of list items
(e.g., Crowder, 1976; Greene & Crowder, 1984) and independent of voca
bulary size (Turner et al., 1987). The findings thus lead to the concl
usion that auditory and mouthed recency and suffix effects are not med
iated by the same underlying source.