The characterization of ductile polymers with ductile fracture behavio
r is still a controversial subject. Presently, two approaches based on
fracture mechanics have been proposed for the evaluation of impact fa
ilure of plastics, i.e., the method using the concept of essential fra
cture work, and the crack initiation and propagation approach. This pa
per discusses the validity of the fracture parameters used in these ap
proaches. Additional experimental results and evidence are presented;
they indicate that the concept of essential work of fracture cannot be
used to characterize the fracture property of plastics. At high loadi
ng rates, the fracture energy of plastics can decrease with crack exte
nsion, resulting in a variable essential work of fracture. It is also
found that the work dissipated in the outer plastic zone as formulated
in the concept does not only reflect the non-essential work but is al
so related to the fracture process. Instead, the approach based on two
material parameters should be used to evaluate the impact fracture be
havior. Crack initiation and propagation energies should be considered
to account for the variation of material's fracture behavior during c
rack propagation so as to include time rate and size scale effects.