L. Abbeduto et K. Short, RELATION BETWEEN LANGUAGE COMPREHENSION AND COGNITIVE-FUNCTIONING IN PERSONS WITH MENTAL-RETARDATION, Journal of developmental and physical disabilities, 6(4), 1994, pp. 347-369
Research on the relation between language comprehension and cognitive
functioning in persons with mental retardation is reviewed. The purpos
e is to evaluate the validity of the clinical practice of cognitive re
ferencing. In cognitive referencing, an individual is considered to be
a good candidate for (i.e., likely to benefit from) entry into a reme
dial language program only if he or she displays a mental age in advan
ce of his or her language age. The studies reviewed concern: (a) the r
elation between various aspects of language comprehension (e.g., pragm
atic, syntactic) and mental age, (b) the relation between different co
gnitive (e.g., sequential analysis, short term memory) and language co
mprehension, (c) the stability of the relation between language compre
hension and cognition over development, and (d) whether remedial langu
age services can lead to levels of comprehension that exceed mental ag
e expectations. The evidence suggests that the theoretical assumptions
underlying cognitive referencing are incorrect, with the result being
that many persons with mental retardation who could benefit from reme
dial language services may not receive those services.