Fossil-Konservat-Lagerstatten from a limited time frame can be classif
ied in a way that provides predictive value, demonstrating that it is
possible to prospect for additional deposits of exceptionally preserve
d fossils. Q-mode cluster analysis reveals that eight Silurian Lagerst
atten in North America are divisible into two groups on the basis of b
iotic components and sedimentary features: eurypterid-phyllocarid-domi
nated (EP) biotas (Williamsville, Syracuse, Pointe-aux-Chenes, Kokomo,
Waubakee) and dendroid-graptolite-characterized (DG) biotas (Brandon
Bridge, Lecthaylus, Mississinewa). All fossil deposits are characteriz
ed by fine-grained, laminated, carbonate sediment bearing evidence of
anoxic depositional conditions. The EP biotas were deposited in hypers
aline peritidal lagoons limited stratigraphically to Upper Silurian st
rata surrounding the Michigan Basin; similar Lagerstatten may be predi
cted for this type of setting in North America and elsewhere in strata
of like age. DG biotas are taxonomically, ecologically, stratigraphic
ally, and areally more diverse than EP biotas, and these Lagerstatten
are less easily predicted.