The hypothesis that the efficacy of hydrophobic antioxidants in animal
models of atherogenesis may, in part, be related to physical effects
on cholesteryl. esters in cells was probed with analogs and metabolite
s of probucol. The interactions of an effective bis-thiomethane analog
(MDL 29,311) and selected metabolites of probucol with cholesteryl ol
eate were examined by differential scanning calorimetry and polarized
light microscopy. Like probucol, MDL 29,311 and the bisphenol metaboli
te decrease the liquid-crystalline phase transition enthalpy of choles
teryl oleate with increasing concentrations. At 20 mol%, no transition
is detectable. By contrast, the spiroquinone metabolite of probucol a
nd the diphenoquinone metabolite common to both molecules have minimal
effects on the liquid-crystalline transitions of cholesteryl oleate.
At 20 mol%, neither compound has as great an effect as 1 mol% MDL 29,3
11. Consistent with their effects on dry cholesteryl oleate, MDL 29,31
1 and the bisphenol metabolite convert lipid inclusions in cells suppl
emented with cholesterol to an isotropic physical state similar to tha
t observed with probucol. The number of anisotropic inclusions in the
cells decreases with increasing concentration in the medium in the ran
ge of 50 to 250 mu g/mL. In cells fed with the spiroquinone or dipheno
quinone metabolites, the lipid inclusions are liquid-crystalline and r
esemble those observed with cholesterol-fed controls. These data are i
nterpreted in terms of a model in which hydrophobic antioxidants close
ly related to probucol disrupt the packing of cellular cholesteryl est
ers.