An experimental comparison of the ring-lens and the astigmatic techniq
ues of generating a focus-error signal (FES) in optical disk systems r
eveals that the ring lens generates a FES curve over two times steeper
than that produced by the astigmat. Partly because of this large slop
e and partly because of its diffraction-limited behavior, the ring-len
s scheme exhibits superior performance characteristics. In particular,
the undesirable signal known as feedthrough (induced on the FES by tr
ack crossings during the seek operation) is substantially lower than t
hat observed with the astigmatic method. The ring lens is easy to alig
n and has reasonable tolerance for positioning errors.