C. Wainryb et E. Turiel, DOMINANCE, SUBORDINATION, AND CONCEPTS OF PERSONAL ENTITLEMENTS IN CULTURAL CONTEXTS, Child development, 65(6), 1994, pp. 1701-1722
In 2 studies, we assessed concepts of personal entitlements in more an
d less hierarchically organized cultures. Study 1 assessed the judgmen
ts of 88 adolescent and adult males (mean ages 17-6 and 34-7) from Dru
ze and Jewish communities in Israel. Subjects were presented with conf
lict situations in which a person in a dominant position (husband, fat
her) objects to the activities of a family member in a subordinate pos
ition (wife, daughter, son), and vice versa. Druze subjects attributed
more power than Jewish subjects to husbands and fathers over wives an
d daughters, but concepts of personal entitlements were prominent in b
oth groups. Study 2 assessed the judgments of Druze females (mean ages
12-10, 17-5, and 38-6). Results show that females accept the legitima
cy of males' power and personal autonomy, recognize the consequences f
or those in subordinate positions, and regard the existing social arra
ngements as unfair. Overall, the findings indicate that social reasoni
ng is heterogeneous in different types of cultures.