G. Klebe et al., DIFFERENT APPROACHES TOWARD AN AUTOMATIC STRUCTURAL ALIGNMENT OF DRUGMOLECULES - APPLICATIONS TO STEROL MIMICS, THROMBIN AND THERMOLYSIN INHIBITORS, Journal of computer-aided molecular design, 8(6), 1994, pp. 751-778
A relative comparison of the binding properties of different drug mole
cules requires their mutual superposition with respect to various alig
nment criteria. In order to validate the results of different alignmen
t methods, the crystallographically observed binding geometries of lig
ands in the pocket of a common protein receptor have been used. The al
ignment function in the program SEAL that calculates the mutual superp
osition of molecules has been optimized with respect to these referenc
es. Across the reference data set, alignments could be produced that s
how mean rms deviations of approximately 1 Angstrom compared to the ex
perimental situation. For structures with obvious skeletal similaritie
s a multiple-flexible fit, linking common pharmacophoric groups by vir
tual springs, has been incorporated into the molecular mechanics progr
am MOMO. In order to combine conformational searching with comparative
alignments, the optimized SEAL approach has been applied to sets of c
onformers generated by MIMUMBA, a program for conformational analysis.
Multiple-flexible fits have been calculated for inhibitors of ergoste
rol biosynthesis. Sets of different thrombin and thermolysin inhibitor
s have been conformationally analyzed and subsequently aligned by a co
mbined MIMUMBA/SEAL approach. Since for these examples crystallographi
c data on their mutual alignment are available, an objective assessmen
t of the computed results could be performed. Among the generated conf
ormers, one geometry could be selected for the thrombin and thermolysi
n inhibitors that approached reasonably well the experimentally observ
ed alignment.