Riparian areas have not responded consistently to grazing systems, sug
gesting that more knowledge is needed to explain how different areas r
espond to specific stresses. Several studies were conducted to determi
ne herbaceous plant response to simulated grazing on riparian areas. O
ne low-elevation redtop (Agrostis stolonifera L.) site in Oregon and 2
high-elevation sedge (Carex spp. L.) sites in Idaho were studied for
3 years. Several combinations of defoliation, compaction, nutrient ret
urn, and season of use were examined. The redtop community responded t
o spring, fall, or spring-fall defoliations by maintaining or increasi
ng the following year's aboveground biomass production. The sedge comm
unities maintained or decreased the following years's biomass producti
on after spring, mid summer, or late summer defoliations. An increase
in forbs occurred in 1 sedge community following spring defoliations t
o 1- or 5-cm residual stubble heights. The most consistent plant respo
nse among areas was reduction in height growth and biomass production
following compaction treatments. When both defoliation and compaction
are considered, it appears that spring, fall, or spring and fall grazi
ng to a 5-cm stubble height on the redtop site would not decrease ripa
rian herbage production. In contrast, when defoliation, compaction, an
d nutrient return effects are considered in the mountain meadow sedge-
dominated communities, grazing once annually during the growing season
to a 5-cm stubble height in the spring, or to a 10-cm stubble height
in late summer, or at a utilization rate exceeding 30% of the total an
nual biomass production can reduce herbage production significantly. R
esults suggest that many of the land management agency riparian guidel
ines would maintain biomass productivity in these sedge-dominated comm
unities.