M. Alessiani et al., ASSESSMENT OF 5-YEAR EXPERIENCE WITH ABDOMINAL ORGAN CLUSTER TRANSPLANTATION, Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 180(1), 1995, pp. 1-9
BACKGROUND: Upper abdominal exenteration (resection of the liver, stom
ach, spleen, pancreaticoduodenal complex, and part of the colon) for t
he treatment of otherwise unresectable tumors is one of the more radic
al operations in oncology. This study was done to analyze retrospectiv
ely a five-year experience with exenteration in 57 patients treated wi
th variations of resectional and transplant reconstructive techniques.
STUDY DESIGN: Sixty-one transplantations were performed upon 57 patie
nts. Three different organ replacement techniques were used: liver-pan
creas-duodenum en bloc (original procedure), liver only (modified proc
edure), and liver plus pancreatic islets. The diagnoses were cholangio
carcinoma (20 patients), hepatocellular carcinoma (12 patients), endoc
rine neoplasms (14 patients), sarcoma (six patients), and adenocarcino
ma of the pancreas (two patients), colon (two patients), or gallbladde
r (one patient). Analyses of survival and tumor recurrence were strati
fied by procedure variations, type and extent of tumor, and immunosupp
ressive regimen. RESULTS: The three month and one, two, three, and fiv
e year actuarial patient survival rates were 82, 56, 38, 33, and 30 pe
rcent, respectively. Eighteen (31.5 percent) of the 57 patients are al
ive after 425 15 (standard deviation) months (range of 17 to 61 months
) and 12 patients are tumor free. The actuarial survival rates stratif
ied by transplantation procedure, immunosuppression, and tumor diagnos
is and extent showed no statistically significant differences beyond t
he three different transplantation groups. Endocrine tumors had a bett
er three-year survival rate (64 percent) than sarcoma (44 percent), he
patocellular carcinoma (25 percent), cholangiocarcinoma (20 percent),
and the other adenocarcinomas (20 percent). Twenty-three patients (40
percent) died as a result of tumor recurrence. Patients with combined
factors of no lymph node involvement, absence of vascular invasion, an
d metastases to the liver only (11 patients) had the lowest incidence
of recurrence (27 compared to 73.5 percent, p=0.006). CONCLUSIONS: Pat
ients with unresectable endocrine neoplasms, fibrolamellar hepatocellu
lar carcinoma, and selected cholangiocarcinoma confined to the liver c
an benefit from this radical operative approach. Patients with sarcoma
can achieve long survival periods but have a high recurrence rate.