Ja. Ekaterinaris et Fr. Menter, COMPUTATION OF OSCILLATING AIRFOIL FLOWS WITH ONE-EQUATION AND 2-EQUATION TURBULENCE MODELS, AIAA journal, 32(12), 1994, pp. 2359-2365
The ability of one- and two-equation turbulence models to predict unst
eady separated flows over airfoils is evaluated. An implicit, factoriz
ed, upwind-biased numerical scheme is used for the integration of the
compressible, Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations. The turbulent
eddy viscosity is obtained from the computed mean flowfield by integr
ation of the turbulent field equations. One- and two-equation turbulen
ce models are first tested for a separated airfoil flow at fixed angle
of incidence. The same models are then applied to compute the unstead
y flowfields about airfoils undergoing oscillatory motion at low subso
nic Mach numbers. Experimental cases where the flow has been tripped a
t the leading-edge and where natural transition was allowed to occur n
aturally are considered. The more recently developed turbulence models
capture the physics of unsteady separated flow significantly better t
han the standard k-epsilon and k-omega models. However, certain differ
ences in the hysteresis effects are observed. For an untripped high-Re
ynolds-number flow, it was found necessary to take into account the le
ading-edge transitional flow region to capture the correct physical me
chanism that leads to dynamic stall.