Rh. Swanson, SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS IN THERMAL METHODS FOR MEASURING SAP FLOW IN TREES, Agricultural and forest meteorology, 72(1-2), 1994, pp. 113-132
A measurement of the ascent of xylem sap in a tree trunk. has implicat
ions in the fields of hydrology and physiology. Taken over a sufficien
tly long time period, the quantity of sap flow upward through the stem
must equal transpiration at the leaves. The occurrence of transpirati
on indicates that stomata are open, a necessary condition for gas exch
ange during photosynthesis. Various thermometric methods have been tri
ed to estimate xylem sap flow. The earliest attempts used simple relat
ionships between the first onset of an induced heat pulse measured at
one or more points downstream in the stem from the heat induction site
. This was followed by a compensation technique in which heat flow in
both the upstream and downstream directions was detected to allow for
conduction, as well as advection of heat from one point to another. La
stly, stem anatomy was considered mathematically and various sap veloc
ity (heat pulse Velocity) and sap flux methods (thermal heat balance)
were proposed to place quantitative thermometric methods on a sound ph
ysical and theoretical base. A close examination of modern thermometri
c methods of measuring xylem sap flow will reveal that there is no one
set of theory and instrumentation that is applicable to all sizes or
species of trees. Trees have three major xylem sap conducting systems
that present quite different physical systems from the standpoint of t
he theory of the conduction and advection of heat in the sap stream wi
thin them. Furthermore, an instrumentation technique that may work sat
isfactorily on large tree stems (more than 5-6 cm in diameter) will ge
nerally not work on smaller stems because of unknown heat losses. Ther
mal heat balance (THB) methods are inherently more quantitative than t
hose relying on heat pulse velocities (HPV). However, THB techniques r
equire more complex instrumentation than HPV methods. And, perhaps mor
e importantly, THB methods require considerable power, an important co
nsideration in held situations away from electrical mains. In general
a combination of THB and HPV methods should be the most useful. The qu
antity of sap flow determined with a THE method can be used to calibra
te simultaneous velocity measurements made with HPV apparatus.