Yh. Dai et al., RESPIRATORY RATE AND SIGNS IN ROENTGENOGRAPHICALLY CONFIRMED PNEUMONIA AMONG CHILDREN IN CHINA, The Pediatric infectious disease journal, 14(1), 1995, pp. 48-50
A clinical study was conducted in three Chinese community hospitals to
investigate the reliability of respiratory rate and various clinical
signs in the diagnosis of pneumonia among 54 children less than 5 year
s of age. Anteroposterior chest film was used as the diagnostic standa
rd. The cutoff criterion for rapid breathing was 50 breaths/minute for
infants ages 2 to 11 months and 40/minute in children 1 to 5 years ol
d. Rapid breathing was a better predictor of pneumonia than rales (pos
itive predictive values of 74.5 and 66.9%). Nasal flaring, chest indra
wing, strider and cyanosis of the tongue had predictive values of > 86
%, but these clinical signs were observed in only a small proportion o
f patients. We recommend that village health workers use rapid breathi
ng for diagnosis of pneumonia, rather than auscultation which is diffi
cult and has proved unreliable. Sensitivity, specificity and positive
and negative predictive values are presented for seven signs and sympt
oms of pneumonia.