Consideration of the mortality distributions of 206 European and Near
Eastern Neanderthals (40 associated skeletons and 166 isolated element
s), compared to those of 11 Recent human ethnographic and palaeodemogr
aphic samples and two non-human mammalian samples, indicate that there
is a clear representational bias in the total sample, with too few in
fants and older adults plus too many adolescents and prime-age adults.
Manipulations of the Neanderthal data produce immature mortality dist
ributions within the ranges of the Recent human samples, but they main
tain the high prime-age adult and low older adult mortality. This high
young adult mortality in the Neanderthal sample does not appear to be
a product of differential preservation or recognition of fossil remai
ns or the systematic underageing of older adults. However, it is likel
y to be the product of a combination of demographic stress (associated
with high levels of stress indicators), the effects of pooling across
temporally and geographically diverse and fluctuating Neanderthal pop
ulations, the need for full mobility among all individuals and hence a
dearth of older individuals dying in shelters, and (possibly) differe
ntial disposal of older individuals in shelters. The first three facto
rs support the interpretations of high levels of adaptive stress previ
ously suggested by palaeopathological analyses of their remains.