Gc. Vandesteene et Aa. Zijlstra, ON AN ALTERNATIVE STATISTICAL DISTANCE SCALE FOR PLANETARY-NEBULAE, Astronomy and astrophysics, 293(2), 1995, pp. 541-549
We propose to use the correlation between the distance-independent rad
io continuum brightness temperature and the distance-dependent radius
to determine statistical distances to planetary nebulae. This correlat
ion satisfies two objective criteria which define a statistical distan
ce scale: (1) We obtain the same calibration relation for the large sa
mple of Galactic bulge planetary nebulae as for a small sample of non-
bulge planetary nebulae with well-determined distances, showing that t
he method is applicable to different PN populations. (2) The distribut
ion of the distances to the Galactic bulge planetary nebulae is in agr
eement with the expected distribution of distances around the Galactic
center. Distances could be determined to better than a factor 2 for 9
5% of the planetary nebulae, and on average to an accuracy of about 40
%. It is an essential requirement that the optically thin radio flux a
nd corresponding angular diameter be used in calculation of the bright
ness temperature. We show that the correlation is also reproduced by m
odel calculations of PN evolution. We show that the new calibration of
the Daub scale obtained by Cahn et al. (1992) also gives the correct
average distance to the large sample of bulge planetary nebulae, but g
ives a skewed distribution around the Galactic Center. Models show tha
t this is caused by the fact that for young nebulae the Daub curve doe
s not follow evolutionary model tracks.