Transferring small doses of T cells to heavily irradiated F-1 mice exp
ressing isolated MHC class I or class II differences invariably leads
to rapid death from graft-vs-host disease (GVHD). Paradoxically, GVHD
is mild or absent when irradiated F-1 mice are reconstituted with larg
e doses of unseparated parental strain spleen cells. This applies when
bulk populations of B6 spleen cells are transferred to irradiated cla
ss II-different (B6 x bm12)F-1 mice or class I-different (B6 X bm1)F-1
mice. In this study, we examined whether the donor T cells in long-te
rm spleen chimeras become tolerant to host MHC Ags. On the basis of sk
in-allograft rejection and induction of GVHD on adoptive transfer, the
results show that the donor T cells display strong tolerance to host
antigens; this applies to CD4(+) cells in class II-different chimeras
and to CD8(+) cells in class I-different chimeras. In marked contrast
to the profound tolerance seen by these in vivo parameters, little or
no tolerance is observed in standard in vitro assays. The results illu
strate that typical in vitro tests for alloreactivity are an imprecise
guide to physiologic tolerance of T cells in vivo.