The effect on water separability of three commercial steam turbine oil
s when contaminated with engine oil and/or a commercially available en
hancement additive (designated as Additive X in this paper) for automo
tive lubricants was investigated. Additive X is an after market lubric
ating oil supplement containing conventional crankcase type additives.
All three oils showed degradation of water separability when contamin
ated with as little as 500 ppm (the ppm unit used through out this pap
er is ppm m/m.) of Additive X alone, as little as 500 ppm of engine oi
l alone, or 300 ppm of Additive X and 300 ppm Of engine oil. It is spe
culated that the contamination affects water separability because of i
ts calcium-based detergent component. The contamination at these level
s in the steam turbine oil is not easily detected by trace metal analy
sis commonly used in rapid oil analysis programs. This is of concern b
ecause Additive X and engine oil are often used in industry to coal be
arings during turbine generator maintenance. This study indicates that
such practices could result in unsatisfactory water separation charac
teristics of the turbine oil.