Mh. Longpre et al., EFFECT OF COMPANION SPECIES ON THE GROWTH OF JACK PINE (PINUS-BANKSIANA), Canadian journal of forest research, 24(9), 1994, pp. 1846-1853
The growth and yield of jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) was studied
in even-aged stands of three types: pure jack pine, jack pine mixed wi
th paper birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.), and jack pine mixed with tr
embling aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) growing on moderately well-
drained glaciolacustrine clay soils in the southern tip of the Clay Be
lt of northwestern Quebec. Site index, average DBH, and average height
of jack pine, and the availability of nutrients in the forest floor w
ere compared among stand types. No differences were found in the heigh
t growth of jack pine among stand types. However, diameters of jack pi
ne in mixtures with paper birch were significantly greater than in eit
her pure stands or in mixtures with aspen despite the fact that both m
ixed stand types showed higher forest floor pH and greater concentrati
ons of exchangeable calcium and magnesium than the pure stands. These
results, together with the pattern of height growth of the three speci
es, suggest that the beneficial effect of paper birch on the diameter
growth of jack pine is caused mainly by a reduction in the competition
for light among individual jack pine trees. The silvicultural implica
tions of the results are discussed.