Two of the main models for the explanation of strong visible-light emi
ssion in silicon, namely physical quantum confinement of electrons in
nanometer-size ''wires'' or spherical crystallites, and chemical quant
um confinement to subnanometer-size silicon particles due to the isola
ting effect of oxygen atoms, are considered with regard to a possible
correlation between Raman shift and photoluminescence (PL) peak positi
on. The physical confinement model predicts opposite shifts with chang
ing size of the confinement. In the chemical confinement model, the sh
ift of the gap is not a size effect; it occurs owing to chemical subst
itution of the bond terminators of the silicon atoms. This is accompan
ied by a parallel shift in the Raman frequency. The calculation of the
vibration spectra of small size wires and spheres allows the correct
assignment of experimentally observed Raman peaks. With the help of th
is assignment, the analysis of the observed spectra shows a parallel s
hift of Raman and PL peaks. The calculated frequencies for siloxene de
rivatives (a known manifestation of chemical quantum confinement) are
lower than those observed in most porous silicon samples; still the pa
rallel shift favors the idea of chemical as against physical quantum c
onfinement.